Lovely car and knowing VW build quality it wont give you any trouble. But if it does from experience I know the bills will be big, but then I guess thats no different from a Clio.
You just need to decide do you want practicality over fun?
Yep, correct.
I think that is how i would say, risky to buy brand new vw technology. That ACT engine. I really dont know what kind of typical fault it will have. Then again, DSG is not the worlds strongest gearbox.
Polo is really more refined than 197, but 197 seats are much better. Fuel economony is BIG + for polo, but in the other side of the coin that price dropping for 25k car vs 13k car is huge. I am pretty sure it will drop something like 10k for 3 years easy. Maybe my clio will drop 4k for 3 years.
And i have to say this, i have had my 197 now 1,5 years and it has been pretty much trouble free driving. Something like £700 for service total. (including new front brakes, cambelt&waterpump, spark plugs and normal service. Do i have good unit?
I some way really like 197, but then in the same time i hate because it revs so much in the highway (okay, i live in little town and i dont drive in highways so often).+ side of the 197 is funky looks, pretty rare car here (under 10 in the country).. It is really fast in my opinion in the b-roads and the steering with summer tyres is so damn good..
Last evening i had pretty much sleepless night because i thought this in many aspect. I am so 50/50% for going to order or not. Difficult.
Conclusion: I am now 31 years old, do i really want to go to grandpa club with more refined, quiet and automatic little car.. or just keep bit maniac 197 and enjoy.