R20BTG
Paid Member
Right, let's get this thread back on track (excuse the pun). In Germany I killed the starter motor (again). I order a new one from RPD which was reduced from £220 to £165 (Part number 7711497395):
The design is shit. Let me just put that out there. Power is sent to the motor by a terribly designed cable that is exposed to outside elements. Not only that, it is just brazed onto the connectors at each end.
"One of the main disadvantages is the lack of joint strength as compared to a welded joint due to the softer filler metals used. The strength of the brazed joint is likely to be less than that of the base metal(s) but greater than the filler metal. Another disadvantage is that brazed joints can be damaged under high service temperatures"
Kinda tells you all you need to know really, they just get cooked and the wires fail. There are no symptoms to watch out for, one minute the engine starts on the button, the next minute nothing. It appears that aftermarket manifolds are particularly prone to causing this, even when heat wrapped. I'm speculating but this might be because they sit closer to the starter motor, they might have thinner sidewalls, and they might allow more radiant heat to penetrate the manifold. Who knows.
So, having seen 2-3 others fail in this way I took steps to try and prevent this happening to the new one. I ordered some Funk Motorsport wiring wrap (velcro) and wrapped this around the cable itself.
I also ordered a starter motor heat blanket, and trimmed it to fit around the body of the connectors.
This is held in place with metal zip ties:
Then the whole thing is wrapped again in the heat blanket:
The end result is this:
The downside is that the OEM heat shield no longer fits, as it can no longer attach slide into place, but to be honest it seems to have done nothing to prevent failure anyway, so as far as I'm concerned it can go in the bin.
Taking the old starter motor off revealed, yep, as predicted, the shitty designed exposed cable and brazing has failed completely:
I'll be modifying this with some of the left over heat shielding and a crimped on eyelet connector rather than relying on the brazing, and I'll keep it as a spare.
Renault Clio 197 200 Starter Motor - Renault Parts Direct
Renault Clio 197 200 Starter Motor - Renault Parts Direct - Renault Parts Direct is a web based service from our authorised Renault dealer.
renaultpartsdirect.co.uk
The design is shit. Let me just put that out there. Power is sent to the motor by a terribly designed cable that is exposed to outside elements. Not only that, it is just brazed onto the connectors at each end.
Brazing - Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org
"One of the main disadvantages is the lack of joint strength as compared to a welded joint due to the softer filler metals used. The strength of the brazed joint is likely to be less than that of the base metal(s) but greater than the filler metal. Another disadvantage is that brazed joints can be damaged under high service temperatures"
Kinda tells you all you need to know really, they just get cooked and the wires fail. There are no symptoms to watch out for, one minute the engine starts on the button, the next minute nothing. It appears that aftermarket manifolds are particularly prone to causing this, even when heat wrapped. I'm speculating but this might be because they sit closer to the starter motor, they might have thinner sidewalls, and they might allow more radiant heat to penetrate the manifold. Who knows.
So, having seen 2-3 others fail in this way I took steps to try and prevent this happening to the new one. I ordered some Funk Motorsport wiring wrap (velcro) and wrapped this around the cable itself.
I also ordered a starter motor heat blanket, and trimmed it to fit around the body of the connectors.
This is held in place with metal zip ties:
Then the whole thing is wrapped again in the heat blanket:
The end result is this:
The downside is that the OEM heat shield no longer fits, as it can no longer attach slide into place, but to be honest it seems to have done nothing to prevent failure anyway, so as far as I'm concerned it can go in the bin.
Taking the old starter motor off revealed, yep, as predicted, the shitty designed exposed cable and brazing has failed completely:
I'll be modifying this with some of the left over heat shielding and a crimped on eyelet connector rather than relying on the brazing, and I'll keep it as a spare.