I can see your reasoning for buying the LY. I think I'd go that way. I like new cars and if what you want is the same, but new, then that sounds like quite a good deal. Is it registered yet? It cost me £5k to change from my 3 year old Clio to my 2 year old Mazda (at the time). I don't like spending money on mods, because you'll never get your money back on them. So either way you look at it, you're going to loose money.