Where are people buying these from?
I noticed that http://www.allpartssouthwest.com/acatalog/Special_Offers__CLIO_Mk4_09_2005__664.html say they get theirs from crash damaged cars. I doubt it would be much more expensive to get a pair from renault and they're guarenteed 100% perfect condition
I got mine from a 2nd hand Clio Dynamqiue... Renault swopped mine out for me as a gift...
it is not new, but very close... and free
a little treatment should have them all 100%