If you think back a hot hatch used to be a car that did everything, based on a small family car with better damping, lighter, tuned engine etc. The car that the original hot hatches were based were already quite stripped back of creature comforts compared to today’s cars.
This is where it splits opinions. Some people think a hot hatch is a lighter, focused car that is about driver feedback and fun (like the originals). Some people think it should be a do it all car (like the originals) based on an already overcomplicated creature comfort laden modern hatch.
Each to their own and both types are what the original were all about, just the cars they are now based on are miles apart.