Id say my 197 was quicker. Every 1*2 ive come up against ive gained on them! Even a stripped out trophy ive kept up with! Find some decent country lanes and learn the road, then go there at about 3am and rag the nuts off the clio, and you'll find out how good the car handles and how the car performs at the higher end of the rev range. You'll be buzzing if your a good enough driver to do this! Ive kept up with porsches and not the bottom of the range porsche boxters, im talking about a powerful porsche the one with the big spoiler on the back. He even said when he turned off how amazed he was by my clio!
I think you've been disheartened by your friends saying to you that the clio is slow. Your friends probably drive turbo'd cars and think their untouchable drivers. We all have friends like this if you mix with other petolheads.
I have a mate who has an astra vxr! Biggest ****** going he is. Its a standard astra vxr and he thinks the cars the best thing ever. He drives at 100mph everywhere, thinks his a real top boy in this motor and even worse thinks his a real driver. He slates my clio, and im quite passionate about my car therefore i dont agree with what he has to say about it, and one day he was pissing me off as he was up my ass, i went to 5.5k in 2nd and i just let off going round these roundabouts, he couldnt even pass me, he eventually passed me on the 5th roundabout when the revs dropped and i had to build my way back up to 5k where he had his turbo to accelerate him on. BUT, i was the one laughing at the end of the day, my 2l n/a clio give that astra vxr the hardest time it'll ever have when he tried to pass me. I said on track it would of been a whole different ball game!
You just have to remember, that the 197 and 200 are nice cars, for some of us drivers out their they are too nice to max out the handling round a bend because people do not want to take the risk of understeering or spinning out into a curb or lampost, fence etc etc..(espechially this time of year!) But if you was to max out the handling capablities of the clio, believe me you'll wipe the smiles off your snobby petrolhead pals and their opinion of the car would drastically change!
As i said, on track its a whole different ball game. Ive been on track days and i found myself staying with cars well out of the clios league!
Cheer up mate thats all i can say! Sell up if you want to take an 'opinion' to heart. Most of us on here including me are mad petrolheads and we all have experiance when it comes to cars, just take a look at the replies on this post and reconsider you own opinion of your clio.