Four Year Service - To bleed the clutch or not?

Would value your experienced opinions on this.

My 2012 200 is going in for its four year service. As much as it pains me, I will use Renault as it's still covered by the 4+ service package it came with, therefore the service is free. I'm aware the schedule calls for the coolant and brake fluid to be changed at this service.

Having done some reading around the usual gearbox woes, difficulty to engage first gear when cold, syncro crunching etc. I was thinking about applying as much preventative servicing as possible during its life. The gearbox oil was changed about 1000 miles ago to Elf NFP, which I think made a huge amount of difference to its feel and ability to select gears when cold. It's a low mileage car having done about 6000 miles from new. It's never been tracked and not been driven hard enough to boil the brake fluid/soften the brake pedal feel. It's just the four/five year old fluid that could begin to cause issues.

Many people write about the clutch being worth bleeding if gears are tricky to engage when cold, as the fluid in the clutch master/slave and circuit will degrade over time as hydroscopic fluid does. The clutch seems fine to me, but from cold even with new 'box oil I have to be very gentle with it (sometimes doubling the clutch or selecting another gear), moving to be more forceful once and a while; like in winter.

I'm aware the brake and clutch system share the same reservoir (therefore the same ageing fluid), but understand there are two separate brake and clutch circuits and master cylinders. Correct?

i) If two separate circuits, does this mean the fluid in the clutch circuit always remains separate from brake circuit?

ii) If the fluid in the clutch circuit remains separate and isn't exposed to a hard life does it really need bleeding/changing? (Renault don't do it as part of the service)

iii) Should I even bother having it bled as I've read it can easily be screwed up (this is Renault we're talking about here, not a good indy).

iv) Do you think it would just be good practice to bleed the entire system (both brake and clutch) when the fluid is being changed?

It would seem sensible to bleed the clutch and get new fluid in the circuit if you ask me. Otherwise, either the four year old fluid mixes with the new if the circuits aren't separate, or the clutch circuit keeps the ever ageing fluid in it, until the clutch needs replacing or someone decides to do it.

Thoughts?
 
Bleed brakes and clutch to replace all fluid

It a simple task (when you've done it once) on your back so for Reno on a ramp it will take only a few minutes. Interestingly we find we get a better clutch pedal by pumping the system manually rather than using an easy bleed.
 
Bleed brakes and clutch to replace all fluid

It a simple task (when you've done it once) on your back so for Reno on a ramp it will take only a few minutes. Interestingly we find we get a better clutch pedal by pumping the system manually rather than using an easy bleed.

Thanks Paul. Surely it has to be best policy to bleed every circuit when the fluid is being changed to avoid contamination between old and new fluid; heaven knows why Renault don't do it as part of the service routine when brake fluid is changed; oh hang on, it's Renault we're talking about here isn't it : )

Other views also welcomed.
 
Don't think it can do any harm do bleed the clutch..did mine some time ago and it made a good diff..
 
Don't think it can do any harm do bleed the clutch..did mine some time ago and it made a good diff..

Thanks Pav. Good to know it made a good difference.

Although 'do no harm' and a Renault main dealer are not two things I associate with each other...
 
Honestly if you're that worried about Renault screwing it up, get it done from a specialist near you. These cars aren't meant to be run on a budget and you can't put a price on piece of mind.
 
Honestly if you're that worried about Renault screwing it up, get it done from a specialist near you. These cars aren't meant to be run on a budget and you can't put a price on piece of mind.
Fair point. Budget not an issue, location of specialist is. Being based in London where do you go? Mark Fish? RenTech in Portsmouth? Now R Sport in Wimbledon has stopped servicing options are limited.

Do what I do just px for a new car
They're pretty disposable Renault's aren't they. Not something I do though.
 
Last edited:
Fair point. Budget not an issue, location of specialist is. Being based in London where do you go? Mark Fish? RenTech in Portsmouth? Now R Sport in Wimbledon has stopped servicing options are limited.

I usually go to Two Techs for certain jobs. Everything else is done by my local indie. You could also try Concept Motors in Rainham who are on the other Clio forum.
 
[MENTION=2045]Yiannis197[/MENTION] is in London, he may be able to recommend a good garage to use that's local for you.
 
Unfortunately no specialists around here and Mark Fish is pretty far from London as well (depending where you live in London of course).

I take my car to the trusted local garage for the easy stuff (while I'm always over the shoulders of the mechanic) but for "heavier" jobs I take it to Sean"Jade Develpments. Quite a trek but it's really worth it, and I don't mind the run either:smile:

Moving on topic, I would bleed the clutch as well, not on every change but once in four years for sure, in fact more often than that. And no, I wouldn't trust Renault mechanics for that, in fact I wouldn't trust the dealership to do any work on my car!!
 
Unfortunately no specialists around here and Mark Fish is pretty far from London as well (depending where you live in London of course).

I take my car to the trusted local garage for the easy stuff (while I'm always over the shoulders of the mechanic) but for "heavier" jobs I take it to Sean"Jade Develpments. Quite a trek but it's really worth it, and I don't mind the run either:smile:

Moving on topic, I would bleed the clutch as well, not on every change but once in four years for sure, in fact more often than that. And no, I wouldn't trust Renault mechanics for that, in fact I wouldn't trust the dealership to do any work on my car!!

Thanks Yiannis. RenTech in Portsmouth is my usual choice, but a 140 mile round trip, so not much less than Jade Developments. Mike knows what he's doing though, and trustworthy. No such thing as a 'trusted local garage' in my book, unless I happen to know them personally; which I don't in the London area.

I completely agree re the clutch. I'm amazed that Renault don't include it as part of the service schedule given every four years they recommend the entire system is drained and refilled; bar the tiny amount that remains in the clutch circuit!